James-Lange Theory
- the emotions are essentially physical in nature, and bodily changes come before, and cause, emotional changes.
Let’s do a quick thought experiment!
- Imagine you are about to sit an exam and you are feeling very nervous. Your mouth is dry, you have a sinking feeling in the pit of your stomach, the palms of your hands are sweaty, and you want to go to the washroom.
- Now remove each of these physical symptoms one by one. What is left of your exam nerves?
- When all the physical symptoms of nervousness were removed, the nervousness disappeared itself.
- In conclusion, if you remove the physical symptoms the corresponding emotion disappears.
- If you mimic the appropriate physical symptoms you can generate the corresponding emotion.
E.g. if you smile, you will feel happy; if you scowl you will feel angry.
Empathy: When talking to someone who is feeling depressed, you unconsciously mimic some of the physical expressions of his mood.
Criticism to James-Lange theory
- It ignores the fact that emotions have both a mental and a physical aspect—our beliefs can affect the emotion.
- The role of beliefs differs human emotions from the emotions of other animals.
- What is your response to the emotion being conveyed in The Scream?
- What if the human figure was replaced by a dog in the same pose?
Comments
Post a Comment